Best of 2008 - Digital SLR Camera Competition

Primaries schmimaries. Your vote is so obviously well spent here: we're asking you to make your selection for best DSLR camera. Simply browse through the models we've assembled below and add your pick to the tally. Hopefully next year you'll be able to call in your vote via Mini Phone while sitting on your Tole Pure.

 

	Pentax K20D	- 70% | 11013 votes
	Pentax K200D	- 5% | 813 votes
	Nikon D90	- 3% | 588 votes
	Canon EOS 5D Mark II	- 3% | 555 votes
	Nikon D700	- 2% | 427 votes
	Canon EOS 50D	- 2% | 351 votes
	Samsung GX-20	- 1% | 280 votes
	Pentax K2000	- 1% | 264 votes
	Canon EOS 450D	- 1% | 227 votes
	Nikon D3x	- 1% | 227 votes
	Canon EOS 1000D	- 1% | 176 votes
	Nikon D60	- 0% | 128 votes
	Sony DSLR-A900	- 0% | 118 votes
	Sony DSLR-A350	- 0% | 75 votes
	Olympus E-420	- 0% | 74 votes
	Sony DSLR-A200	- 0% | 53 votes
	Olympus E-520	- 0% | 52 votes
	Panasonic Lumix DMC-G1	- 0% | 47 votes
	Sony DSLR-A300	- 0% | 38 votes
	Olympus E-30	- 0% | 31 votes

Altogether 15537 votes from January 12, 2008

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Voters Comments

Comment number: -1-

The 40D is an amazing camera. It has lightning fast AF in almost any light from very bright to very dim. The framerate is a great boon for sports photography and the user interface is beautifully constructed. While I don't find the Custom shooting modes very useful, and I feel that the Auto ISO function was forced in to the camera without proper consideration for how it would function, the camera's numerous other features are stellar. The dust busting system is much better than that of the XTi. The AF accuracy is second to none (except maybe the 1D MkII/N, and the viewfinder is one of the most wonderfully comfortable to use APS sized viewfinders that I have ever used.

The camera is really sturdy, the only quibble I have with the whole thing is that it doesn't have weather seals, so during rainy days a ziplock is necessary.

As is always the case the images are what counts, and the 40D really delivers under any circumstance.

Fejsakin at 09:16:10 on 2008-01-17

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -2-

Nikon D300 is an excellent camera, outstanding performance (IQ & fast) very happy with decision to buy this, no regrets at all.... At first I was a little reluctant to buy due to not being confident with the ease to use, but I adapted quite quick & now is awesome - I wont look back.... I have installed the D2X mode & customized all custom settings to suit my shooting style..

Madlen at 09:36:12 on 2008-01-17

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -3-

I just have switch my old Olympus E-510 to E-3, and so far, i found that this is a superb camera, with a rich feature and excellent image quality. Price for Performance ratio is also very good for me compared to other brand which are 3 X more expensive, for same class....

Mark29 at 09:39:22 on 2008-01-17

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -4-

Pretty interesting results!

Fardi at 13:09:50 on 2008-01-17

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -5-

Nikon D90 is the best DSLR camera sub 1000$ as of Dec 2008. Great IQ, ergonomic body construction, user friendly menu, light weight, easy to find lenses, HD video clip is a plus.

Gery at 08:12:25 on 2008-12-30

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -6-

I agree with you! I had the Sony A700 before, which was better build and faster. I bought the D90 because of video. I don't regret it. Video is a very nice feature. I'm now waiting the day, when Sony annonce a full-frame camera with video to switch back, because I miss the Anti-vibration in-body.(Nikon has only one fast lens 2.8/70-200 VR)

Meggy44 at 08:15:12 on 2008-12-30

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -7-

This is my first digital, and I am quite happy with it's image quality. Before purchase this came I have made lot of study in dpreview. Finally I got the SX110 that gives more that what I expect.

Canon SX110 owner at 11:45:03 on 2008-12-30

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -8-

Canon G10 is an outstanding advanced point and shoot camera. I bought this camera to replace a simple point and shoot camera (Canon SD750) because I wanted more control over the exposure settings without the bulk and expense of a SLR. The picture quality is excellent. The build quality is outstanding, all metal body, controls feel solid. At first I thought it was a bit heavy and big, but that's comparing it to the SD750, not really a fair comparision considering it has so much more to offer. After I uploaded my first set of pictures to my computer, there was no going back, truly outstanding. Critics complain that the movies aren't HD, but come on, how large of movie files do you want. The movies are very good and smooth. This is the best pro-amature camera on the market. To get any better, you have to jump up into the SLR range, and with it comes price and bulk

MikiG at 07:09:51 on 2008-12-31

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -9-

Well this is clearly just a count up of all the owners of each camera. No one is going to say that a different camera is better than their own...

IsaacE at 14:51:38 on 2008-12-31

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -10-

Well, I wouldn't vote for my own camera, it is clearly not "the best" now. But how many people here have really been able to test the various brands and models to make a educated determination of which camera is better than another. Like most reviews and polls, this is a shallow play toy aimed at the easily amused and is biased by those easily influenced by marketing hype. (in addition to being open to simplistic cheating resulting in wildly skewed and inaccurate results) In short, its a joke.

AJ at 16:48:39 on 2008-12-31

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -11-

The Pentax K20D is the best ~$1000 camera in 2008 and the K200D is the best sub $1000 camera in 2008. Both have in camera shake reduction and are weather sealed and well made. Other bodies in these classes feel like toys. Plus, the bodies work well with "Legacy" glass including m42 mount glass.

Blue at 21:05:19 on 2008-12-31

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -12-

They all have their strengths, but Pentax gets you a great all around camera that you'd have to spend loads more cash to outdo with other brands. It's versatile, well built takes great pictures, pentax lenses are top quality and you can use eny kmount or m42 ever made easily

Ian at 12:41:00 on 2009-01-01

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -13-

I voted for the Pentax K20D, I own two, plus a K10D as a back up. I switched from Canon just after the K10D was released, who could resist a weather sealed body at that price. I locked on a 30 year old Pentax manual lens and instantly got better result than I had been getting for years with my Canon kit, I did a wedding the week after using 20 year old KA mount lenses and it was the best I had ever shot. I'm sure glad I kept my Pentax Z1P and all my old lenses

wedding_snapper69 at 00:18:27 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -14-

Canon 450D gets my vote. Pentax are crap they always have been. Who needs weather ealing anyway? what sort of idiot is going to use a DSLR in the rain.

Canonman at 00:24:36 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -15-

"Who needs weather ealing anyway? what sort of idiot is going to use a DSLR in the rain." Why not, if you can? Seems to me you might be missing out on some shots...

Egbert Eyeliner at 01:04:51 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -16-

I have four Canon cameras. Been shooting with Canon's since 1977. I voted for the Nikon d700.

Buckaroo at 01:49:06 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -17-

Wow, someone's got a case of the Mondays, and the weekend isn't even here yet. "Who needs weather ealing anyway", er, umm, eh? Someone needs a spell checker. I have used the Pentax in the rain many times. I'm out there getting superb shots while the rest of the photographers sit indoors waiting for the rain to break. Sort of sad, really. :-)

Joshua at 02:44:04 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -18-

Pentax D20 rocks weather sealed body is very useful when going out in the field and the weather changes, as mentioned shared the old glass.

Timothy Dwight Morton, APSA at 02:44:09 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -19-

K20d for me, superb quality and excellent lenses. With a VERY good price It can't be beaten!

climber at 09:28:45 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -20-

Pentax get my vote. You can't beat them for value in my opinion and thier old glass is first rate. Perhaps Canonman would like to elaborate on his ignorant "crap" comment. probably never used one in his life.

Pentax-rule at 09:36:45 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -21-

Somebody seems to be getting upset lol, Ive always found slagging off something without trying it is at best pathetic. All the cameras on this poll have their pros and cons, but I researched well before I chose the Pentax K20d. Its IQ is as good as any, low light noise levels on a par with the d700, very effective in body Shake reduction makes it work with any lens,dust alert and dust removal system, multiple exposure and extended bracketing,burst mode at 21 fps which gives pseudo movies if you want that sort of thing. Couple that with shock and weather resistant body and lenses (DA*) which I have used to produce stunning images in extreme environments makes the Pentax K20d the best dslr of 2008

wildweatherphotographer at 10:04:18 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -22-

Why do people buy Canon when they can get better build quality with Pentax? Compared to an EOS450 the K20d feels like REAL quality, and that goes for the photo quality as well.

P.F.Shooter at 12:12:49 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -23-

"Why do people buy Canon when they can get better build quality with Pentax? Compared to an EOS450 the K20d feels like REAL quality, and that goes for the photo quality as well. " Maybe they care about things like AF and access to some of the best lenses around, or maybe they want to shoot with a 35mm sensor. I voted for the D700. It is an excellent all around camera for the price. The 5DII would have been my second choice.

sharpshooter at 16:54:07 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -24-

Sharpshooter - Pentax user do care about AF and your knowledge is obviously limited as the K20D has Auto Focus!

The Pentax K20D with DA* lenses is an excellent combination that has top quality glass and the advantage of weather sealing so if you are caught out by a shower or want to photograph sports when the weather may change, you can do so without worrying about potential damage or having to keep the camera and lens inside a plastic bag. It is ideal for snow, or waterfalls.

Maybe you should try a K20D and you will soon see why it is such a good camera.

Speysider at 18:03:55 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -25-

I find it funny how those leaving negative comments will grab at any straw to make their point regardless of how little sense it makes in the real world. "Maybe they care about things like AF and access to some of the best lenses around,"? eh? my point exactly... As stated, the camera does have AF, duh! Also, Pentax is still known for making some of the best optics around. People need to do some research before commenting on blind faith. Anyway, it is obvious from the scores above, that this site, for the most part, is visited by educated consumers!!

Alberto at 18:22:59 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -26-

Penyax K20D!.........superb camera!......price for price a world beater....and all those amazing old lenses,quality glass cant beat it!........

Beginner! at 19:00:54 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -27-

Sorry about the spelling...must put my other glasses on!...should read Pentax!.........pity they dont do reading glasses..lol

beginner at 19:03:11 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -28-

Actually - Pentax do make reading glasses, or at least the lenses and they are premium lenses, not the run of the mill standard ones.

Speysider at 19:16:10 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -29-

My K200d is much better than my old Sony, and I can use my old, excellent M42 mount lenses. OK canon's can as well, but the Pentax is just so much more solid and durable, and it's weather sealed for when I get caught in the rain. Best camera of 2008? My vote goes to the Pentax.

Ross Brook at 19:41:04 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -30-

Voted for Pentax. About weather sealing.. it was sad view, looking at Canon owner jumping back and forth between shelter and subject just because it was slightly raining. He did that 5 or 6 times. Well, I just kept shooting with K200D and 16-50 DA*. Keep shooting :)

huha at 20:25:20 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -31-

I voted for the D60, have used Nikon since the 80s but its nice to see Pentax get their finger out and start producing great cameras again. Most of the guys at my Camera Group are Canon users, we have one guy there used an old Pentax (dont ask me what) and the Canon guys constantly took the mickey, despite the fact he still won most of the trophies, six months ago he showed off his K20D, god you should have seen the envy in those Canon guys faces, made me wish Nikon would do something similar, at the same price of course.

NikonNick at 21:10:56 on 2009-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -32-

What is this, a pentax website? I'm sorry, but Pentax optics do not compete with Canon and Nikon. Some of the better Pentax lenses are just rebranded Tokinas...nice lenses, but not exactly top of the line. And yes Pentax has AF, but it isn't as fast or reliable as the competition...it just isn't. How many sports shooters do you see using Pentax? A DSLR is a system and the lenses and total performance need to be considered when making a purchase.

sharpshooter at 06:45:32 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -33-

He sharpshooter, Maybe it's time to recalibrate your scope. Or buy a Pentax one of course :>). Just tell me why there are so many after market adapters, that allow Canikon users to mount Pentax glass on their camera body. Ever saw a adapter that makes canon glass work on another brand body???? Ever heard of the Limited series of Pentax? And for your info, Sports isn't the only field of Photography. I am the first to admit, there are faster AF systems on the market. But don't degrade the quality of Pentax glass or the K20D for that matter. The combination of K20d with the SDM lenses makes a very powerful and capable one. And I haven't even mentioned the factor Value for Money, compared to Canikon. Have a nice day, Martin.

Malo 1961 at 08:19:19 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -34-

"Some of the better Pentax lenses are just rebranded Tokinas" Now, THAT is FUNNY!! What was that someone was just saying about arguments making little sense in the real world? Wow, this guy truly has little grasp on reality. Regardless of which body you prefer, Pentax optics are known world wide as top of their class. This is just the most nonsensical comment I've seen on here yet. I am getting so much entertainment from reading Sharpooter's comments. :-) Can't wait to see what he writes next.

Fred at 11:38:00 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -35-

"I'm sorry, but Pentax optics do not compete with Canon and Nikon."

It's absolutely true that there are excellent lenses from both Canon and Nikon, otherwise (you would hope) people wouldn't use them. But there's always this emphasis on bigger and faster, and okay, if you're a sports or wildlife photographer a system with high frame rates and the longest lenses may well be best for you. Pentax don't currently have high frame rates, or huge lenses. But they do make superb lenses. Yes, some of them were developed in partnership with Tokina. Tokina have also released rebranded Pentax lenses.

Take a look at this article:

http://www.luminous-landscape.com/columns/sm-02-05-02.shtml

It's a few years old now, but just so you know a little more about the lenses you're dismissing. Then read this one:

http://photo.net/columns/mjohnston/pentax-35mm-lens/optical-discussion/

Note the quote at the end of that article "It really is just beautiful, and will gratify…no, it will spoil anyone who likes the very best optical quality and appreciates what truly outstanding lenses can do. It ranks right up there with the best lenses I’ve ever used in any format."

I think what you probably meant was that the lens range from Pentax isn't as great as that from the Nikon and Canon, and that's true. Pentax lenses cover 10mm to 300mm at the moment, which for 90% of photographers is almost certainly more than enough.

"A DSLR is a system and the lenses and total performance need to be considered when making a purchase."

That's true. No arguments there. And the people who use Pentax have considered this, and made their purchase, because they appreciate excellent build quality and features, quality of lenses, range of focal lengths, value for money...

Of course, the original question was to "make your selection for best DSLR camera", nothing about the system as a whole anyway.

Egbert Eyeliner at 12:22:32 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -36-

Hey Guys, I thought this was a POLL? not open warfare! I get the impression that there are quite a few Canon users out there who are really p!$$£d off that Canon have finally been knocked off the top perch, and the votes for the K20D obviously reflect this, I also get the feeling that some of you Pentax guys are getting your own back for all the years of scorn Canon users have poured on you for the last 15 years, well good on you I say. Personally I dont care who wins cuz at the end of the day all the cameras listed here are damm fine pieces of equipment and all have thier place in the hobby or even the workplace, who cares if Canon produce the best bodies and lenses for sports or wildlife, I dont!

NikonNick at 13:14:24 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -37-

Open warfare? :-) No, just a little discussion!

If you go into a camera shop these days and buy a DSLR you will have one that is capable of producing great results, no matter what brand you get. It just needs to be remembered that you have a choice, and to make your own mind up about what is right for you.

I'm sick to death of hearing a customer say "I want to buy an SLR" and a shop assistant handing them a Canon and replying "You want one of these..." That's not how it should be, because everyone has different needs.

In my line of work I get to handle various cameras, mostly at the lower price range, and find some of them feel horribly cheap, some are better made, some have quite baffling controls or long winded ways to adjust things like ISO, others are better.

Simple things like two (customisable) control wheels make the K20D (and K10D before) easier to control than other cameras in a similar price bracket. I don't personally use the TAv and Sv modes, but I know plenty that do, and value those extra features.

Spot metering has only just been introduced on the 450D, Pentax have included this on all their DSLRs so far (even the new K2000/Km).

It seems to me that Pentax do as much as they can for the price, whereas Canon do the opposite.

But I'm happy as long as someone has weighed up the pros and cons of all the systems, and made an informed choice. If that's a Canon, Nikon, Sony, Olympus or Pentax, good for them, they did the right thing. Listening to a uninformed shop assistant, or anyone that says "X brand are best, the others are crap" is, in my opinion, the wrong thing to do.

Egbert Eyeliner at 16:44:24 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -38-

Well said Egbert, as Nikonnick says the cannon boys are feeling like everybody else does when their chosen brand is overlooked in favor of big bucks handouts from one manufaturer or another, ensuring a 'top' rating in a biased test. Uk magazines that I've seen rave about Cannon, forgetting that they're playing catch up all the time, for example live view on the 450, old idea and not as good as the Olympus original. Then there was the first14.5 meg CMOS sensor from,let me see, ohyes Pentax. Cannon suddenly upped the meg count to out do a better camera, I could go on. Read the reviews in the panel alongside this poll,sharpshooter, then adjust your views. There are other, sometimes better, alternatives to cannons.

P.F.Shooter at 17:05:48 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -39-

Hang on a minute, I AM A CANON USER and I for one DO NOT bash other kit in favour of my own, you folks seem intent on branding ALL Canon users with the same iron. I respect and appreciate the efforts of every manufacturer, yes even Pentax! (why are there no smilies on here LOL) I wont go into lengthy detail why I chose Canon but it wasnt because a salesman told me to. As I recal Pentax have introduced a lot of firsts to the photography world, didn't they produce the very first AF SLR? The K20D is a top notch bit of kit and I take my hat off to Pentax. I think its time those Canon and in some cases Nikon users who are eager to slag off Pentax woke up and smelled the coffee, I also think Pentax owners should also back off from rubbing it in that their chosen brand has produced a winner.

thedoctor at 18:25:35 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -40-

Sorry doc didn't mean to upset ALL canon users, I must admit to wanting an EOS 1D mk111, but can't afford one! Still Pentax may go that way soon and I have lenses that fit their bodies.

P.F.Shooter at 18:42:31 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -41-

"I for one DO NOT bash other kit in favour of my own, you folks seem intent on branding ALL Canon users with the same iron." I think this is somewhat inaccurate for the most part. A lot is in response to one person who started an attack with "Pentax is crap". I believe the remainder are simple statements to the contrary in a vain attempt to defend against one individual. (FYI, You should never argue with an idiot. They bring you down to their level and then beat you with experience.) As has been stated, plenty of good points all around regardless of the brand. But no matter what whiz-bang feature the camera might have, it is the person behind it that turns an otherwise normal snapshot into a masterful photo.

Jonsy at 22:53:09 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -42-

[quote] But no matter what whiz-bang feature the camera might have, it is the person behind it that turns an otherwise normal snapshot into a masterful photo. [/quote] Yep...you are right. But just in case....we use Pentax !! Just kidding.........lol Martin.

Malo1961 at 23:02:13 on 2009-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -43-

What a wonderful discussion, and I can't but agree with several posters that all the DSLRs currently on the market are excellent and each has thier pro's and con's. I selected Pentax for thier value for money and thier exceptional LTD range of lenses.

Happy K20 owner at 06:37:54 on 2009-01-04

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -44-

Sorry people but may I be allowed to throw the proverbial spanner in the works, I bought myself the Olympus E30 because after many happy years with my OM system I decided to give Olympus DSLRs a go, my girlfriend on the other hand was a die hard Pentax fan with a collection of models dating back to the 60s, guess what? she wont let go of my E30 and I end up toting around her heavy and cumbersome K20D, its like having a brick around your neck, in fact I'm sure it could be used for putting windows through with no adverse effects to the camera, what I'm trying to say is the F***ing thing is solid as a rock, this may be all well and good for the likes of wedding_snapper69 and other pro's but who want to tote a brick around on vacation?

OM at 00:59:20 on 2009-01-05

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -45-

I voted K20D, of course, I do own one, but mainly for the reasons that have been stated. Its extremely good value for money, feels great, is made well, has great high ISO capabilities, the weather sealing works, and I like shooting with it! Note that although I agree Pentax have fantastic lenses (the FA and DA LTD, and the *series), I excluded this from my opinion. OM, You have to look at it from a different point of view, but you basically answered your own question. Different cameras suit different people.

RobB at 01:41:14 on 2009-01-05

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -46-

"OM, You have to look at it from a different point of view, but you basically answered your own question. Different cameras suit different people." I realise that, my girlfriend has had years of using diminutive Pentax film bodies (her favourite is the MX I believe) and she freely admits the K20D was a bit of a shock to her system, she does use it of course but guess who ends up toting it around. It is actually a pain in the ass because we cant remember who shot what on which camera. I know it has nothing to do with this poll but I am impressed with the SDM lenses though, I would rate them as good as or even marginally better than some of my old Zuiko lenses.

OM at 18:18:02 on 2009-01-05

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -47-

Now I normally refrain from posting in discussions like this but lets lay it down. I have used the D300, 40D, 5D and K20D, each has strengths and weaknesses but as it is now, the best bang for the buck on the market is the K20D. Please note not the BEST! Just best for the money overall. There are holes in the lens line up and some qc issues to deal with but the results I have speak for themselves. I even have a few 5D and D300 owners seriously considering swapping systems after they see what I have done with the K20D, ( tho that will change once I start playing with when ever the latest wiz bang new kid on the block camera is ). Lets not brand other camera systems or owners, lets just vote on what we think is the best of the year.

torphoto at 20:36:50 on 2009-01-05

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -48-

I voted for the K20D, as I just got one a couple weeks ago. Who could turn down the Adorama deal for $699 for body+18-55 lens kit??? Went to my cousins for New Year's Eve - she recently bought an XSi. No offense meant for XSi owners, but dang, that thing felt plasticky and flimsy! When she played with my K20, and shot a few snaps, she regretted her decision. After we got to playing, and I taught her some of what I had learned, she wanted to start shooting raw. Needless to say, she had to pull out the manual, and then go through all the jibberish about what mode it's in, etc... what a joke! All we gotta do is hit the menu button, hit down-arrow 4-5 times, and make your changes! Gotta love it when a product is designed "just right," works "just right," and actually is "just right." Now, does this mean the K20D is the be-all end-all camera that all photogs should get? Of course not - each has their place, function, strengths, etc...

n00b at 07:35:28 on 2009-01-07

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -49-

I voted K20D as well. Best bang for buck out there, hands down.

Jeff at 07:46:33 on 2009-01-07

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -50-

The Lumix G1 is NOT an slr. It does have removable lens but that does not make it an dSLR.

Blue at 00:12:46 on 2009-01-08

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -51-

Actually, that is what I like about Pentax. They seems to put feature that very useful, especially on their lower end. Top LCD panel, focus confirmation on old lens, spot metering. I mean, yes, Live View is nice, but my friend who own e510 rarely use them.

ikhsan at 06:42:55 on 2009-01-08

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -52-

I have nothing but praise for the Pentax K20D, I was out shooting fishermen when I slipped and the K20D momentarilly went under the water, I yanked it out as quick as I could and miraculously the camera survived, God may have given me quick reflexes but Pentax gave me a weather seled body and lens.

johnhoover at 20:54:38 on 2009-01-08

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -53-

The K20d (14.6 MP) and the K200D (10.2mp) have in body shake reduction and weather seals and the k20d also has live view.

Hatchet at 22:02:35 on 2009-01-08

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -54-

What's with the Panasonic Lumix G1 being listed as an dSLR?

Hatchet at 22:03:17 on 2009-01-08

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -55-

"I have nothing but praise for the Pentax K20D, I was out shooting fishermen when I slipped and the K20D momentarilly went under the water, I yanked it out as quick as I could and miraculously the camera survived, God may have given me quick reflexes but Pentax gave me a weather seled body and lens." Excelent! I heard of one guy who tested his Pentax by taking it into the shower, DONT ask me what he was photographing LOL.

NikonNick at 12:28:59 on 2009-01-10

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -56-

I dont believe johnhoovers comments for one bit, no camera could survive a dunking into water like that, not even a so called weather sealed body, and as for NikonNicks post about the idiot who is supposed to have taken a camera into the shower, I think someone has a very vivid imagination. The k20 body may have a few seals here and there but water would still get in around the lens mount and it would still get into the lens and trash that, I think someone is having a laugh.

canonman at 17:28:16 on 2009-01-11

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -57-

Canonman - you jump to conclusions without looking at what there is. The Pentax DA* lenses are also fully sealed, the mount is sealed and the body does not have a "few seals hear and there" but 78 seals. There are numerous reports of them being dropped in water with no adverse affects and there are plenty of Pentax users (myself included) who have no problems using the camera in torrential rain. Check the facts before you criticise.

Speysider at 18:42:07 on 2009-01-11

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -58-

As a Canon user I have to say I am troubled by canonmans comments, he seems a little disturbed that there may be a better camera out there than his precious 450D, I'll stand with thedoctor insofar as I agree that the K20D is a camera worthy of winning this poll, had I not so much money invested Canon gear I may well be tempted to switch brands. Canon DSLRs have been lacking in innovation for quite a wee while now and I think the Pentax K20D may make Canon sit up and take notice that they have some serious competition.>>>>>I voted for the 50D by the way LOL

thelaird at 19:08:05 on 2009-01-11

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -59-

"As a Canon user I have to say I am troubled by canonmans comments" TRAITOR, call yourself a Canon user HAH! THIS POLL IS RIGGED BY PENTAX SPIES DONT BELIEVE ANYTHING YOU READ THE CANON 450D SHOULD BE TOP OF THIS POLL NO QUESTION ABOUT IT.

canonman at 21:14:45 on 2009-01-11

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -60-

Oh Dear! send for the men in the white coats.

NikonNick at 22:14:52 on 2009-01-11

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -61-

What planet is canonman on? Can't he see that there is a deffinate swing towards value and away from fashion? Send the men in the white coats for him!

P.F.Shooter at 22:28:11 on 2009-01-12

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -62-

Well, yes. There is a chance that the result of the poll is rigged, as it allows you to put multiple votes. But that doesn't make Pentax camera not the best bang for the buck, or their user are satisfied with their purchase :)

ikhsan at 01:55:05 on 2009-01-13

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -63-

2 out of the last four don't make sense! It looks like spammers have logged in. Moderators beware, it may be time to close thread/voting. I own a Sony and a Pentax so I know what people mean by 'value for money'

Climber at 08:21:52 on 2009-01-13

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -64-

Question by canonman "Canon 450D gets my vote. Pentax are crap they always have been. Who needs weather ealing anyway? what sort of idiot is going to use a DSLR in the rain." Answer 1 "A professional" would be my guess, but then what would I know only being a K20D owner. I wonder why they sell Canon EOS Weather Sealed Lenses

not canonmans friend at 16:12:56 on 2009-01-13

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -65-

My Pentax camera's have serverd me very well for the last 25 years and, in fact still do, including all thoes old lenses! The K20 may not still be in use 25 years from now, though it is built to last. What ever Pentax camera I am using then, I am sure to still be using those same lense! Pentax respect the photographer and give them a highly capable tool at a very competative price.

David at 11:14:23 on 2009-01-14

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -66-

My vote goes to the Samsung GX20 because its MY camera, but I agree that Polls like this are a waste of time, the Olympus E30 for example is only at the bottom of this list because not many E30 owners have found this poll or bothered to vote. Anyone wishing to buy a DSLR would do well to ignore the voting when making a choice and take more note of comments made by individual owners (well the SANE ones at least) then go to a store and try EVERY brand before making a final decision, DONT take notice of salesmen either, they'll only want to sell you the one with the biggest profit margin, I know, I used to work in photo equipment sales.

tomtom at 19:15:39 on 2009-01-14

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -67-

tomtom has just about given the best possible advice yet, as a pro photographer I cant stipulate enough how important the feel of a camera is in your hands, a camera should feel good right from the start, dont skimp on cost, buy one that feels solid and well made. For general photography ANY of the DSLRs listed above will perform adaquately, as a pro I use Nikon gear but in my line of work both Pentax and Canon would be equally as suitable, the Pentax would have the edge because of the image quality and access to top notch lenses but as said, for general photography ANY would be OK, just buy one that feel right.

photo-pro at 00:25:20 on 2009-01-15

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -68-

All the cameras listed are good - period. Brand loyalty should have nothing to do with voting (though I see it does). I voted for the Pentax K20D because for the price, around $700 now, and the vast number of inexpensive lenses available (around 50 years worth).

Old Photog at 13:31:31 on 2009-01-15

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -69-

Nice pool!

Barry at 08:37:30 on 2009-02-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -70-

K200D低端的价格，准中端的质量性能，买了一点都不后悔

Michael at 08:58:38 on 2009-02-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -71-

7D is absolutely the best for me!

Kevin at 14:30:03 on 2009-12-31

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -72-

Nikon P90 is the best super zoom ever!

M Gerhard at 15:35:55 on 2009-12-31

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -73-

Nice pool

Kelly54 at 16:05:41 on 2009-12-31

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -74-

I have only seen and held a preview model (Mark IV). but it specs out great and seems to have addressed all of the problems the Mark III had. So my vote goes to Mark IV!

Deny29 at 08:22:37 on 2010-01-01

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -75-

Canon SX200 is a good all round camera to carry around when I don't have my SLR. Been using it for 3 days now and it seems quite versatile, accurate and does deliver on most fronts. Overall a great wee camera.

meme at 08:47:53 on 2010-01-01

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -76-

Just saw a TV news report: which a woman dropped her camera (pretty sure it was an Oly 8000) from a bridge into a river, from which it was carried into a lake. After five weeks it was "caught" by a fisherman, and returned to her. She was found from the plate on a vehicle on one of the photos. The camera still works, and she claims it gives her better results than four others she owns. I don't have one of these, but give it a five for construction!

KaminT at 09:07:04 on 2010-01-01

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -77-

K-7! Go go go!

Dave Le at 13:04:32 on 2010-01-01

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -78-

I've owned Canon 7D camera for just over a week, but I've used it extensively and have tried most of the features, so I feel entitled to expressing an opinion. In one sentence, this is a great stills camera. It's efficient, quick, precise, user-friendly and produces very high quality images, even at high ISO speeds. The contrast between the 7D and the 350D that I had previously owned (and kept) is striking. Canon 7D is the king!!!

Mely at 13:38:52 on 2010-01-01

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -79-

The best cropt camera of 2009 and the best since I moved to Digital format.

Rakesh at 15:43:46 on 2010-01-01

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -80-

The K-7 is nearly idel. It is compact, amazingly well built, fits my hand like a glove and has more features than anyone could possibly want.

Archie at 18:08:02 on 2010-01-01

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -81-

It's a pain to have to vote for something that I've never seen (Nikon D3S) but I am a D3 owner and it is revolutionary. I have been an avid photo hobbiest for 30 years. I bought a Mamiya M645 29 years ago trying to improve performance to the point where I could capture what I was seeing. I was never successful. This camera (D3) and the those from Canon and others that perform even close to this well in low light bring us as close as we've ever been to that goal.

Patrick Drennon at 09:16:54 on 2010-01-02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -82-

The K-x is the best cheap DSLR ever made and that ever will be made. The K-7 is the best pro-quality DSLR. It puts the D3s and all the Nikon junk to shame. Come to any Pentax forum and you'll see I speak the truth.

RMABO at 01:46:20 on 2010-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -83-

Isn't this popularity contest sort of list useless. Other than the camera they bought, few on the list have ever seen the others in person. Some are clearly as high as they are due to marketing efforts not performance. Some of these models still have real problems with AF performance, and exposure consistency. I voted for the D3s because it is the only one on the list that is genuinely a bar raiser. Other cameras with the same low light spec on paper have been shown to fail to deliver. In basic camera performance some, while adding features are actually going backwards in real image quality.

stanj at 12:05:12 on 2010-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -84-

You may be think that this consest is useless but for us Pentaxians it is us only chances to win the prises and awardts that we deserf. every thing that pentax produsses beets all the canikon producks. it is onley becuse nikon and cannon pay big $$ to the revew sites that they lie and say pentax is no good. Pentax make cameras for reel photogrphers not snubs!!!

RMABO at 20:39:14 on 2010-01-03

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -85-

RMABO sounds like quite a fanboy :) anyway i had oportunities to try out several on top of this list including canon 7D and pentax k-7 and i must say that k-7 is the best camera of 2009(at least for my purposes)

SNYR at 07:57:26 on 2010-01-04

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -86-

Pentax K-X.. its awesomeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee 10/10 for the little Master.. :)

Aj at 14:46:03 on 2010-01-04

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -87-

There are other cameras out there 'better' than the K-x, but realistically there hasn't been anything remotely comparable in 2009 in the 'bang per buck' stakes, given Pentax's commendable policy of not crippling entry-level cameras by omitting AF motors, spot metering, legacy lens compatibility etc. A huge step from a small player, and I look forward to the response from the big two.

Sunny Dave at 15:49:49 on 2010-01-04

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comment number: -88-

I didn't just buy the Pentax K-7 for no reason you know.

Le, Dave D. at 21:00:48 on 2010-01-05

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Add Your Comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this article. All spam postings will be removed. To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or email address. You can include only one URL. Line breaks and paragraphs aren't automatically converted - you need to use <p> or <br> tags.